Thursday 24 April 2014

CORMAC McCARTHY VS JAMES M CAIN



BLOOD MERIDIAN 

keen to follow the kid / strong rootless drifting / big country beautifully realised / but the kid disappears in a rockfall of nameless characters / then i liked it again - the country is a powerful character / then i was bored for ages / then the kid is back ! gets a weird earless friend / then i'm bored again for ages / towards the end i like it again because i'm near the end but what the hell is happening ? sense of missing the point / being taken for a clever ride / the judge is a classic character creation tho / i picture an epic film looking good on paper but a controversial five hour cut / top heavy / ambitious and NOT bad but wheres the SOUL ? style and content battle for clever points and the reader is left in the cold . . .

whereas 

SERENADE 

is just plain pure poetry set literally to music 



No comments:

Post a Comment